Skip to main content

Comparison between two retail companies picked are Walmart and Costco

The two retail companies picked are Walmart and Costco whose 2017 Financial statement links are provided below: WALMART https://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/ wmt/financials?query=income- statement COSTCO https://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/ cost/financials?query=income- statement Both organizations are well known brands and position themselves well with their customer base. Walmart’s value proposition is “We save people money so they can live better”. On the other hand, Costco’s value proposition is “All-in-one convenience and everyday affordability”. Both retailers focus on cost saving for their customers. Looking at their financial statements and by analyzing them a few key areas are evident when comparing the two organization. Looking at the current ratio and quick ratio we can determine the short-term solvency of each organization. The current ratio can be determined by dividing the assets by the liabilities. Walmart’s current ratio sits at 0.86 while Costco’s sits at 0.99. The quick ratio is c
1 comment

Often, celebrities contract to endorse a product, but should they use the product regularly, or even like the product before they are allowed to claim that they “endorse” the product?


Marketing mix involves four P’s variables: product, place, price and promotion that should be used in marketing strategy to ensure value is delivered (Winer & Dhar, 2011). When celebrities are endorsing any product, it’s part of promotion. Based on law, promotion should not lie about price, quality and purpose (Jacoby & Meyers, n. d.). It is better to endorse product that they use but legally if they are not misleading consumers with false information, it is not illegal. Having celebrities in promotion may encourage consumers to buy the product but they must be targeted appropriately (Olenski, 2016). Can you imagine famous athlete endorsing house hold product like laundry detergent? The impact of endorsement depends on number of factors such as celebrity and product match, celebrity and target audience match besides their regular popularity values (Jain, 2011).

For example: Gordon Ramsay’s funny commercial about Chef. The commercial is funny. He has not provided any false information on any price, quality or purpose of any food and he is probably the right celebrity to do this advertisement because of the product and celebrity match.

Another example is Activia yogurt commercial. Activia commercial have Jamie Lee Curtis, a famous spokesman but since the advertisement made false statement about scientifically proven health benefits, later Dannon company had to pay $45 million to consumers who filed lawsuit and many consumers stopped buying this product (Weinmann & Bhasin, 2016).

So, my answer is, legally they can endorse any product if they tell the truth and not provide false information to consumers but for more impact, celebrity and product match is important to consider as well.

If you were assigned to sell a product called “Sweet Treats” with the slogan, “so sweet, it will make you tweet,” but you thought the product tasted sour, and not at all sweet, what would you do?

I would not accept the job to sell that product because I would not be the face of the product and giving the false information about the product. The first thing is it is illegal to provide false information about product and secondly if I am not convinced, I cannot convince other people to use it.

Explore where the line is between harmlessly implying that someone is promoting a product, and someone dishonestly claiming that they genuinely believe the product is the best.

If they are not providing wrong information about product, price, use without any proof, they are not crossing the line. It is ethically wrong to claim that they genuinely believe the product is the best unless they have tried every product from all competitors and have comparison report that also support the statement. It is better not to mention misleading information to differentiate the product from other competitor products that may create legal or ethical controversies in future and impact the brand. It is very difficult to recover the position in the market once consumers lose confidence and trust in the brand. If we consider some of the most successful advertisements such as the advertisements of Coca-Cola, Nike etc. we notice that these companies are selling product by associating the product with the consumer’s emotion rather than claiming what product can do nor talking about the product itself nor comparing with competitor products. In Nike’s advertisement “Just Do It” (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1J6Qx7l49tQ), the girl just enjoys dancing wearing that shoes. Similarly, in Coca-Cola’s “Open Happiness” advertisement (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7ADWd9Psag) doesn’t say anything about the product. That’s the most powerful marketing. Without telling anything, you are connecting the product with the consumer’s emotion. If we take another example of Activia commercial (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLDHK_RiXFc ), it is falsely claiming that it has scientifically proven health benefits. Because of dishonest claiming, most consumers stopped buying this product. 


References:

Winer, R., & Dhar, R. (2011), Marketing management (4th ed.). Boston: Prentice Hall. Retrieved from:https://my.uopeople.edu/pluginfile.php/270824/mod_resource/content/2/TEXT%20Marketing%20Management_Part1.pdf

Federal Trade Commission (2015, June 15), Truth in Advertising. Retrieved on Jul 29, 2018 from: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/media-resources/truth-advertising 

Jacoby & Meyers (n. d.), False and Misleading Advertising. Retrieved on Jul 29, 2018 from: http://www.jacobymeyers.com/false-and-misleading-advertisi.html 

Jain V. (2011, Mar), Celebrity Endorsement and Its Impact on Sales: A Research Analysis Carried Out in India. Global Journal of Management and Business Research Vol 11 Issue 4 Version 1.0 ISBN: 0975-5853. Retrieved from:

https://globaljournals.org/GJMBR_Volume11/8-Celebrity-Endorsement-And-Its-Impact.pdf 

Olenski S. (2016, Jul 20), How Brands Should Use Celebrities For Endorsement. Retrieved on Jul 29, 2018 from: https://www.forbes.com/sites/steveolenski/2016/07/20/how-brands-should-use-celebrities-for-endorsements/#14e2b74e5593

Weinmann K. & Bhasin K. (2011, Sep 16), 14 False Advertisement Scandals That Cost Brands Millions. Retrieved on Jul 29, 2018 from: https://www.businessinsider.com/false-advertising-scandals-2011-9?op=1


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

TATA SKY OR TATA SQUEEZE!!

This is my debut article in the interest of Indian consumers. Just my humble contribution; to enlighten them about the product or service of famous TATA SKY. Amir Khan, the brand ambassador or Mr. Ratan Tata, the person at the helm of all TATA affairs, would be ashamed of TATA SKY, once they know instead of making the life “JINA LALA”; it is turning the life “JINA HARAM” with TATA SKY at times. With much expectation I switch over to TATA SKY from local cable operator in the month of May this year. Within six months twice I they have replaced their set top box. They went out of order and it is under warranty for one year. Every time I called their customer care, they receive they call as if your are naïve. They take no less than half an hour, to guide you to switch off and on , take out their digi-card and put it back, whether you are young or old caring a fig for that! Surprisingly their call centre’s number is not toll free! You are put on hold for ten minutes and another twenty m
23 comments
Read more

A trip to TAKI, West Bengal , India

                                   As Bangldesh looks on the bank of Ichamoti, from TAKI, West Bengal. Take a closed look, a cattle corpse i s floating on the river bed, near the Bangladeshi bank. Victim of transborder cattle smuggling. I am not sure how young generation would react to the name of yester year’s one of the most popular writer portraying the essence of rural Bengal, its pains and joys, prosperity and poverty and off course the thread of society; Bibhuti Bhusan Bandopadhyay. His simplicity was eminent in is writing; that was best projected by famous film director Satyojit Roy in his internationally acclaimed films like ‘Pother Panchali’, ‘Aparajito’ et el.  At the age of 9, I read ‘Pother Panchali’. Though I was not matured, enough to comprehend its intrinsic message of the content but the very story left a pugmark in my mind. I became more interested about the author later. The river ‘Ichamoti’ ; again and again surfaced in his rendition; so in my mind. I always cher
29 comments
Read more

If you were assigned to sell a product called “Sweet Treats” with the slogan, “so sweet, it will make you tweet,” but you thought the product tasted sour, and not at all sweet, what would you do?

Often, celebrities contract to endorse a product, but should they use the product regularly, or even like the product before they are allowed to claim that they “endorse” the product? If celebrity is lying, that is endorsing a product he/she does not use/consume then the ad should be pulled.  The Federal Trade Commission requirement that ads or sponsored social media posts indicate so - is not enough to inform consumers. (Robert, 2017) So, yes, a celebrity who endorses a product should at least appear in public using the product. Examples go in the opposite direction, instead of claiming to use a product but not doing so, which would be lying, the Kardashians post product endorsements across several social media platforms either without disclosing it is an ad or waiting until hours or days after the initial post to do so. According to the the organization Truth in Advertising (TINA.org) The delay allows avid followers to see the initial post as a testimonial instead of as an ad. (Kilke
Post a Comment
Read more